The short answer: a good protein shake is 1 scoop of protein powder, 1 cup of cold milk or milk alternative, 1/2 cup of ice and one flavor add-in, blended about 30 seconds. The 10 blends below all start from that formula and take 5 minutes.

  • Key numbers: 1 scoop powder · 1 cup liquid · 1/2 cup ice · 1 fruit or nut-butter add-in · 30 seconds in the blender
  • Top moves: put the liquid in first, freeze a ripe banana for thickness, and add a spoonful of nut butter so the shake does not taste chalky
Jump to recipe

Prep time: 5 minCook time: 0 minTotal time: 5 minServings: 1 shake

Below: the formula, 10 protein shake recipes, swaps for dairy-free and no-banana versions, fixes for thin or chalky shakes, and how to keep one ahead. If you are still choosing a powder, start with our protein powder guide. For fruit-forward blends without powder, see healthy smoothie recipes.

The protein shake formula

Part Amount Options
Protein 1 scoop (follow the label) Whey, casein, soy or pea powder; or 1/2 cup plain Greek yogurt
Liquid 1 cup, cold Milk, soy milk, unsweetened almond or oat milk, or water
Body 1/2 cup ice or frozen fruit Frozen banana, berries, mango or cauliflower rice
Flavor 1 add-in Peanut butter, cocoa, instant coffee, cinnamon, vanilla

Basic protein shake ingredients

  • 1 cup cold milk or milk alternative
  • 1 scoop protein powder (vanilla or unflavored works with every blend below)
  • 1/2 cup ice
  • 1 add-in from the table below

Directions

  1. Add the liquid first. Pour the milk or water into the blender so the powder cannot cake on the bottom.
  2. Add the rest. Add the protein powder, ice or frozen fruit and your flavor add-in.
  3. Blend. Blend on high about 30 seconds, until smooth with no clumps.
  4. Taste and adjust. Add a splash more liquid if it is too thick, or a few more ice cubes if it is too thin. Drink right away.

Rate this recipe

10 protein shake recipes

Each blend uses the basic formula (1 scoop powder, 1 cup liquid, 1/2 cup ice) plus the add-ins listed. Use chocolate powder where the blend says chocolate and vanilla powder everywhere else.

# Shake Add-ins Powder
1 Chocolate peanut butter 1 tablespoon peanut butter, 1/2 frozen banana Chocolate
2 Strawberry banana 1/2 cup frozen strawberries, 1/2 frozen banana Vanilla
3 Vanilla almond 1 tablespoon almond butter, a pinch of cinnamon Vanilla
4 Mocha 1 teaspoon instant coffee, 1 teaspoon cocoa powder Chocolate or vanilla
5 Blueberry oat 1/2 cup frozen blueberries, 2 tablespoons rolled oats Vanilla
6 Mint chocolate 1/4 teaspoon peppermint extract, 1 tablespoon cocoa powder Chocolate
7 Tropical 1/2 cup frozen mango or pineapple, a squeeze of lime Vanilla
8 Cookies and cream 2 crushed chocolate sandwich cookies, 1/4 teaspoon vanilla extract Vanilla
9 Peaches and cream 1/2 cup frozen peaches, a pinch of cinnamon Vanilla
10 Banana bread 1/2 frozen banana, 2 tablespoons rolled oats, a pinch of cinnamon and nutmeg Vanilla

Protein shake recipes without protein powder

You can build the protein from food instead. Blend 1/2 cup plain Greek yogurt or 1/2 cup cottage cheese with 3/4 cup milk, fruit and a drizzle of honey. Blend the cottage cheese with the milk first so it turns smooth, then add the fruit. These shakes are thicker and tangier than powder shakes, which works well with berries and peaches. For more whole-food protein ideas, see high protein foods and high protein snacks.

Dairy-free and no-banana swaps

If you want Swap Notes
Dairy-free Unsweetened almond, soy, oat or coconut milk Soy milk is the creamiest; pick a powder that is dairy-free (pea, soy or rice)
No banana 1/2 cup frozen mango, peaches or cauliflower rice Cauliflower rice adds body with almost no flavor
Thicker Extra ice, frozen fruit, 2 tablespoons oats or 1/4 avocado Blend 15 seconds longer
Lighter Water instead of milk Add a teaspoon of vanilla extract so it tastes less flat
Less sweet Unflavored powder and unsweetened milk Sweeten with a few drops of honey only if needed

Fix a thin, chalky or clumpy shake

  • Chalky: blend instead of shaking, use cold liquid, and add a fat such as peanut butter or a frozen banana.
  • Clumpy: pour the liquid in first, then add the powder, and blend at least 30 seconds.
  • Too thin: add frozen fruit, ice or oats, and blend again.
  • Too thick: add 1/4 cup liquid at a time until it pours.
  • Too foamy: let it rest 1 minute after blending, or blend with the lid on and the ice added last.

Make ahead and store protein shakes

Blend the shake the night before, pour it into a sealed jar and keep it in the refrigerator, then shake or stir before you drink it. A shake tastes best the same day. Refrigerate any made shake within 2 hours, as USDA guidance on leftovers and food safety says for perishable food. For grab-and-blend mornings, portion the frozen fruit and oats into freezer bags, then add the liquid and powder when you blend.

Plan protein shakes into your week

Shakes are a quick breakfast or snack, so slot them where the week is busiest. Pair them with real food from your high protein meals rotation, and use meal planning on a budget to keep frozen fruit, milk and powder on one shopping list. Browse all Home & organizing printables.

Made this? Tell us how it went

Your notes help the next cook: what you changed, how long it took, how it turned out.

Your rating (optional)

No email needed. Comments are read by a person before they appear; links and ads are not published.

More drink recipes you'll love

See all drink recipes

Frequently asked questions

How do you make a protein shake? To make a protein shake, blend 1 scoop of protein powder, 1 cup of cold milk or a milk alternative, 1/2 cup of ice and an optional fruit or nut butter add-in until smooth, about 30 seconds. Add the liquid first and the powder last so the powder does not stick to the bottom of the blender.

What can I mix with protein powder besides milk? You can mix protein powder with water, unsweetened almond, soy or oat milk, coconut water, brewed and chilled coffee, or plain yogurt thinned with water. Milk and soy milk give the creamiest shake, while water gives the lightest one.

How do I make a protein shake thicker? Add frozen fruit, a few ice cubes, a spoonful of nut butter, rolled oats or a quarter of an avocado, and blend longer. Freezing a ripe banana in chunks is the most reliable way to get a thick, milkshake-style texture.

How do I make a protein shake without it tasting chalky? Blend instead of shaking, use cold liquid and ice, and add a fat or a frozen fruit such as peanut butter or a frozen banana to round out the texture. Letting a blended shake rest for a minute also lets the foam settle.

Can I make a protein shake without protein powder? Yes. Blend plain Greek yogurt, milk or soy milk, silken tofu or cottage cheese with fruit and a little honey. These shakes are thicker and tangier than powder shakes, and cottage cheese blends smooth when you blend it with the liquid first.

Can I make a protein shake ahead of time? You can blend a shake the night before and keep it covered in the refrigerator, shaking or stirring before you drink it. It tastes best the same day, and any shake left out should be refrigerated within 2 hours.

Can I use a protein shake as a meal replacement? A basic shake of protein powder and water is a snack, not a full meal. To make it more filling, add a fruit, a spoonful of oats and a fat such as peanut butter, and consider eating it alongside real food.

Are protein shakes good for weight loss? A protein shake can help you stay on a calorie plan when it replaces a higher-calorie snack and keeps you full, but it is only one part of your eating pattern. Check the label on your powder for calories and added sugar, and count everything you blend in.

Which protein powder should I use? Use any whey, casein or plant-based powder whose flavor you like and whose label lists protein, calories and added sugar clearly. Our protein powder guide explains the types and how to choose one.

Where can I save my favorite shake? The Family Recipe Binder ($6.99) from HomeBase Paper Co. keeps your favorite shake and its ratios on one printable page.

Newsletter

Get the HomeBase email

Fresh tips three times a week, Mon/Wed/Fri, with our deals and new products, from printables, spreadsheets and bundles to paperback planners and apparel, plus simple home, money and planning tips.

Sources

  1. USDA FSIS: Leftovers and Food Safety fsis.usda.gov