The short answer: the most common types of mushrooms in U.S. grocery stores are white button, cremini and portobello, which are all the same species picked at different ages. Next come shiitake, oyster, king oyster, enoki, beech and maitake. Rarer kinds like porcini, chanterelle and morel are usually foraged, so buy them from a trusted grocer, never the woods.
- Quick picks: button or cremini for everyday sautés, soups and pizza · portobello for grilling and burgers · shiitake for stir-fries and broth · oyster for fast sautés and pasta · king oyster for "scallops" · maitake for roasting until crisp
- Handle them right: store unwashed in a paper bag in the fridge, clean just before cooking, and always cook enoki and morels
Checked November 16, 2026 against CDC food safety and poisoning reports, Utah State University Extension's mushroom guide and the federal Poison Help line. Below: a comparison table of 21 edible mushrooms, a short guide to each, how to clean and store them, how to swap one type for another, and a food safety note on wild mushrooms. This is a cooking guide, not a foraging or identification guide.
Types of mushrooms comparison table
All 21 types below are edible when bought from a grocery store, farmers market stall or licensed seller and cooked properly. "Easy to find" is a rough guide to where most U.S. shoppers will see them.
| # | Mushroom | Flavor | Texture | Best cooking uses | Easy to find? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | White button | Mild | Firm, juicy | Sauté, soups, pizza, raw in salads | Every grocery store |
| 2 | Cremini (baby bella) | Deeper, earthy | Firm | Sauté, roast, stews, stuffed | Every grocery store |
| 3 | Portobello | Rich, meaty | Dense, steak-like | Grill, roast, burgers, stuffed caps | Every grocery store |
| 4 | Shiitake | Savory, smoky | Chewy | Stir-fry, broth, ramen, rice | Most grocery stores |
| 5 | Oyster | Mild, slightly sweet | Soft, tender | Quick sauté, pasta, eggs, soup | Many grocery stores |
| 6 | King oyster | Savory, mild | Thick, chewy stem | Sear as "scallops," grill, stir-fry | Asian markets, some groceries |
| 7 | Enoki | Very mild | Crisp, noodle-like | Hot pot, soups, stir-fry (cook well) | Asian markets, some groceries |
| 8 | Beech (shimeji) | Nutty, a little bitter raw | Crunchy | Stir-fry, noodles, soups | Asian markets, some groceries |
| 9 | Maitake (hen of the woods) | Woodsy, rich | Feathery, crisp when roasted | Roast, sear, tacos | Specialty and some groceries |
| 10 | Lion's mane | Mild, seafood-like | Shaggy, tender | Pan-sear as "crab" cakes or steaks | Farmers markets, specialty |
| 11 | Pioppino | Nutty, peppery | Crunchy stems | Pasta, risotto, sauté | Farmers markets, specialty |
| 12 | Chestnut | Nutty | Firm caps, crisp stems | Sauté, stir-fry, pasta | Farmers markets, specialty |
| 13 | Straw | Mild, sweet | Slippery, soft | Curries, soups, stir-fry | Canned at Asian markets |
| 14 | Wood ear | Very mild | Crunchy, jelly-like | Hot and sour soup, salads, stir-fry | Dried at Asian markets |
| 15 | Porcini | Deep, nutty | Meaty | Risotto, sauces, soup (often dried) | Dried in most groceries |
| 16 | Chanterelle | Fruity, peppery | Firm, a little chewy | Butter sauté, eggs, cream sauces | Seasonal, specialty |
| 17 | Morel | Rich, nutty | Spongy, hollow | Cream sauces, pasta (always cook) | Seasonal, specialty |
| 18 | Black trumpet | Smoky, rich | Thin, chewy | Sauces, eggs, pasta | Seasonal, specialty |
| 19 | Hedgehog | Sweet, nutty | Firm | Sauté, soups | Seasonal, specialty |
| 20 | Chicken of the woods | Lemony, chicken-like | Firm, meaty | Sauté, "chicken" dishes | Seasonal, specialty |
| 21 | Truffle | Strong, earthy aroma | Firm, shaved thin | Shaved over pasta, eggs, risotto | Specialty only |
Everyday grocery store mushrooms
These three are the same species, Agaricus bisporus, harvested at different stages. They are the cheapest and easiest types of mushrooms to find year-round.
1. White button mushrooms
The youngest, palest stage. The flavor is mild, so they take on garlic, butter, herbs and sauces. Use them whole in stews, sliced on pizza, or raw in a salad. They are the classic choice for stuffed mushrooms and green bean casserole.
2. Cremini mushrooms
Cremini, also sold as baby bella or brown mushrooms, are a little older than white buttons. They have a firmer bite and an earthier flavor, so they hold up in beef stroganoff, gravy and long-simmered sauces. Swap them in for button mushrooms in any recipe for more flavor.
3. Portobello mushrooms
Portobellos are fully grown cremini with wide, open caps. The dense, meaty texture makes them a popular meatless burger. Brush with oil and grill 4 to 6 minutes a side, or roast and stuff the caps. Scrape out the dark gills with a spoon if you do not want them to turn a sauce gray.
Specialty cultivated mushrooms
These are farmed, not foraged, and many larger grocery stores now carry at least a few of them.
4. Shiitake mushrooms
Shiitake have brown, umbrella-shaped caps and a savory, slightly smoky flavor. The stems are tough, so pull them off and save them for broth. Slice the caps into a stir-fry, fried rice, ramen or miso soup. Dried shiitake add even more depth once soaked.
5. Oyster mushrooms
Oyster mushrooms grow in fan-shaped clusters and come in gray, yellow and pink varieties. They are soft and cook in a few minutes. Tear them by hand rather than slicing, then sauté for pasta, eggs or soup. Add them near the end of long-cooking dishes.
6. King oyster mushrooms
King oysters are mostly thick white stem. Slice the stems into coins, score them and sear in a hot pan until golden for a scallop-like bite. Long strips also grill well, and shredded stems work in tacos.
7. Enoki mushrooms
Enoki grow in bunches of long, thin white stems with tiny caps, usually sold in sealed plastic. Trim off the root end and pull the strands apart. They are a hot pot and noodle soup favorite. Cook them well, not as a raw garnish (see the safety section).
8. Beech mushrooms (shimeji)
Beech mushrooms come in brown or white clusters with small caps. They taste a little bitter raw but turn nutty and crunchy once cooked. Cut off the base, separate the stems and toss them into stir-fries, noodles or soup.
9. Maitake mushrooms (hen of the woods)
Maitake look like ruffled feathers. Pull them into pieces and roast at high heat until the edges crisp. They are rich enough to star in tacos, grain bowls or on top of a steak.
10. Lion's mane mushrooms
Lion's mane is a white, shaggy ball with a mild flavor that many cooks compare to crab or lobster. Slice it into thick slabs and press it in a hot pan to drive out water, or shred it for "crab" cakes.
11. Pioppino mushrooms
Pioppino (also called black poplar) have small brown caps on long, crunchy stems. Their nutty, peppery flavor suits pasta, risotto and simple sautés.
12. Chestnut mushrooms
In the U.S., chestnut mushrooms are a small, orange-brown cultivated mushroom with a nutty taste and crisp stems. In the UK, "chestnut mushroom" is another name for cremini, so check which one a recipe means.
13. Straw mushrooms
Straw mushrooms are small and egg-shaped. In the U.S. you will mostly find them canned at Asian markets. Drain, rinse and add to curries, soups and stir-fries.
14. Wood ear mushrooms
Wood ear, also called black fungus, is sold dried. Soak it in warm water until it softens and grows, then slice it. It adds crunch, not much flavor, to hot and sour soup, salads and stir-fries.
Wild and seasonal mushrooms (buy them, do not pick them)
These types are mostly foraged or very hard to farm, which is why they cost more and show up only in season. Buy them from a trusted grocer or licensed seller.
15. Porcini mushrooms
Porcini have a deep, nutty flavor. Fresh ones are rare in the U.S., so most cooks buy them dried. Soak in hot water for 20 to 30 minutes, then strain and use the soaking liquid in risotto, soup or sauce.
16. Chanterelle mushrooms
Chanterelles are golden, trumpet-shaped and smell faintly fruity. Cook them simply in butter, then fold them into eggs, pasta or a cream sauce.
17. Morel mushrooms
Morels have honeycomb caps and hollow centers that trap grit. Halve them and rinse well. Always cook morels, never eat them raw, and use them in cream sauces and pasta.
18. Black trumpet mushrooms
Black trumpets are thin, dark and smoky. Split them to rinse out grit, then sauté and add to sauces, eggs or pasta.
19. Hedgehog mushrooms
Hedgehogs have tiny spines under the cap instead of gills. They taste sweet and nutty, like a milder chanterelle, and are great sautéed or in soup.
20. Chicken of the woods
This bright orange shelf mushroom has a firm, meaty texture that cooks often use like chicken. Cook it thoroughly and buy it only from a seller you trust.
21. Truffles
Truffles grow underground and are prized for aroma, not volume. Shave a little over pasta, eggs or risotto at the end. Many truffle oils are flavored oils, so check the label.
Mushroom food safety: wild mushrooms can kill
Never eat a mushroom you or a friend picked unless a qualified expert has identified it. Deadly kinds can look almost exactly like edible ones. Utah State University Extension advises buying mushrooms from a reputable grower or grocer instead of hunting them yourself, because misidentifying one can cause serious illness or death.
The risk is real and current. A CDC report counted 39 suspected amatoxin poisonings from foraged wild mushrooms in Northern California between November 2025 and March 2026. Three patients needed liver transplants and four died.
- Do not use photos, apps or this article to identify a wild mushroom.
- If someone eats a wild mushroom and feels sick, or you are unsure, call the free Poison Help line at 1-800-222-1222, open 24/7.
- Enoki: the CDC has linked enoki to Listeria outbreaks and says to cook them thoroughly. Pregnant people, adults 65 and older and anyone with a weakened immune system should not eat raw enoki.
How to clean mushrooms
Clean mushrooms right before you cook them, not when you get home.
- Trim any dried or dirty stem ends.
- Wipe caps with a damp paper towel or soft brush, or rinse briefly under cold running water.
- Pat dry right away so they brown instead of steam.
- For morels, black trumpets and other wild types, halve them and rinse inside to remove grit.
- Pull off shiitake stems and save them for stock.
How to store mushrooms
Utah State University Extension says to keep mushrooms in their original package until you open it, then move them to a paper bag in the fridge. Airtight plastic traps moisture and speeds spoilage. Plan to use them within about 5 days, up to a week.
| Type | Fridge life | Freezer tip |
|---|---|---|
| Fresh button, cremini, portobello | About 5 days to a week | Sauté first, then freeze in ½ or 1 cup portions |
| Delicate oyster, enoki, maitake | Use within a few days | Cook before freezing |
| Dried porcini, shiitake, wood ear | Months in a sealed jar in the pantry | Not needed |
Toss any mushrooms that turn slimy, smell sour or grow mold.
How to swap one type of mushroom for another
Most recipes are forgiving. Match texture first, then flavor.
| If a recipe calls for | Swap in |
|---|---|
| Button | Cremini for more flavor |
| Cremini | Button, or button plus a few dried porcini |
| Portobello | Several large cremini |
| Shiitake | Cremini plus a splash of soy sauce |
| Oyster | Beech or thinly sliced cremini |
| Wild mushrooms | A mix of cremini, shiitake and oyster |
How to cook mushrooms so they brown
Use a hot pan, a little fat and enough room. Crowded mushrooms steam and turn rubbery. Salt near the end, and let the liquid cook off before stirring much. For sheet-pan meals, see our guide to roasting vegetables. Mushroom trimmings and shiitake stems also make a richer vegetable stock.
Mushrooms fit almost any dinner. Try them in chicken marsala, an omelette, French onion soup, or our vegetarian recipes for meatless nights.
Plan mushroom meals on a grocery budget
Button and cremini are usually the best value, so build weeknight meals around them and save specialty types for one dish a week. Prices change by store and season, so track what you pay in a grocery price book. For more ways to cut the bill, read how to grocery shop on a budget and our meal planning on a budget guide, or browse the grocery budget hub.
Browse every planner on the Printables page or the Bundles page, and find more ideas in our meal plans hub and how to meal plan guide.
Frequently asked questions
What are the most common types of mushrooms? The most common types of mushrooms in U.S. grocery stores are white button, cremini and portobello. All three are the same species picked at different ages. Shiitake, oyster, king oyster, enoki, beech and maitake are the next most common, and many larger stores carry them year-round.
How many types of edible mushrooms are there? There are hundreds of edible mushroom species worldwide, but home cooks usually see about 10 to 20. This guide covers 21 types you can buy in the U.S., from everyday button mushrooms to seasonal wild kinds like chanterelles and morels sold by specialty grocers.
What is the difference between cremini and portobello mushrooms? Cremini and portobello are the same mushroom at different ages. Cremini, or baby bella, are young and firm with closed caps. Portobellos are fully grown, with wide open caps, dark gills and a denser, meatier texture that suits grilling and stuffing.
Which type of mushroom has the most flavor? Dried porcini and shiitake have some of the strongest savory flavor. Among fresh grocery store types, cremini and shiitake taste deeper than white button. Wild kinds like morels, chanterelles and black trumpets are also prized for rich flavor.
What is the best mushroom for stuffing? Cremini and white button mushrooms are the best size for bite-size stuffed mushrooms. Portobello caps work for a stuffed main dish. Pop out the stems, chop them into the filling and bake until the caps are tender.
What mushrooms are best for stir-fry? Shiitake, oyster, beech and king oyster mushrooms hold their texture best in a stir-fry. Slice them, cook them in a hot pan with a little oil first, then add the other vegetables and sauce so they brown instead of steam.
Can you eat mushrooms raw? Some mushrooms, like white button and cremini, are commonly eaten raw in salads. Others should always be cooked. The CDC says to cook enoki thoroughly because of Listeria risk, and morels should never be eaten raw.
Is it safe to eat wild mushrooms? Only if a qualified expert has identified them. Deadly mushrooms can look almost exactly like edible ones. A CDC report counted 39 suspected poisonings and four deaths from foraged mushrooms in Northern California in winter 2025 to 2026. Buy wild types from a trusted seller.
What should I do if someone eats a wild mushroom? Call the free Poison Help line at 1-800-222-1222 right away, even if the person feels fine. It is open 24/7. Some deadly mushroom poisonings cause delayed symptoms, so do not wait for someone to get sick before calling.
Should you wash mushrooms? Yes, but only right before cooking. Utah State University Extension says to rinse them under cold running water or wipe them with a damp cloth, paper towel or soft brush. Pat them dry so they brown well, and never soak them.
How long do mushrooms last in the fridge? Fresh mushrooms last about 5 days to a week in the fridge. Keep them in the original package until opened, then in a paper bag. Delicate types like oyster and enoki are best used within a few days. Toss any that are slimy or moldy.
Can you freeze mushrooms? Yes, but cook them first. Utah State University Extension says not to freeze fresh mushrooms. Sauté them, cool them and freeze them in half-cup or one-cup portions to add straight to soups, sauces and casseroles.
Newsletter
Get the HomeBase email
Fresh tips three times a week, Mon/Wed/Fri, with our deals and new products, from printables, spreadsheets and bundles to paperback planners and apparel, plus simple home, money and planning tips.
